Bit of Advice Please

Need any help or advice post it here.
Murray
Posts: 578
Joined: Mon Jun 15, 2026 10:48 pm
Australia

Diamond Dave wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 8:22 am Great thread this guys but has made me realise something major that I and perhaps some others may be missing.....
I am trying to achieve a natural immunity with my birds
and try not to treat for anything. (Dont judge me on tha as its not the crux of this post). In particular for young bird sickness. I have not given them anything for maybe 4/5 years. Have to say that it hasnt got any better. I had birds die on me this year as well as previous years.
But here is the realisation...... why would it get better while I am breeding from the same stock birds each year!!!
I am staggered and feel very stupid that I hadnt thought about this before.
The object of natursl immunity is to breed off the ones that survived it and by continuing to breed off the same birds, I have achieved nothing.
So do I have to do away with my treasured stock birds or is treatment the only way around it?
Give that man a cigar! :D
It is a subject of debate but I am of the opinion that many years of routinely pumping drugs into them has left racing pigeons with anywhere between a slightly compromised immunity and no immune system at all.
I treated them for canker, cocci, respiratory disease etc on a regular basis for years.
Why?
Because I had been told I had to treat them for canker, cocci, respiratory disease etc on a regular basis.
Like all of us.
I don't quite know why or how, but over the last 10 years I have bred a loft full of pigeons that do what they are meant to do.
Breed winners.
They were off stock that have always been treated on a regular basis, yet in my shed they get nothing at all. In fact they seem to breed better pigeons in my loft than where they came from in some cases.
You might expect some to do well on the change of system and some to fail. But they don't. I can't remember a pigeon that didn't bloom in my system.
No, I have no idea why either. :D
Last edited by Murray on Mon Nov 09, 2026 9:46 am, edited 1 time in total.
Murray's Loft
"Well THAT didn't work". :D
User avatar
chrisroscoe
Site Admin
Posts: 487
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2022 3:39 pm
Gender:
Great Britain

Murray wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 7:20 am
chrisroscoe wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 6:25 am mine atm are on 3 days a week Gempax, 1 day week apple cider vinegar, and 1 day a week DAC Pharma Condition-Stimulant ,they have just come off a 5day course of harkers 4-1 also :)

yeah im alittle behind on this post lol but im trying haha still doing 1 room in the house and its kicking my arse
That's interesting to read, Chris.It's good to hear what other people are doing.
Why did you do the course of 4in1, if you don't mind me asking?

its the harkers stuff for cocci canker worms and para i think it says on the bottle haha

i hope it works i think it did because i had one all huntched up and didnt wanna move and now its back to normal :)
User avatar
chrisroscoe
Site Admin
Posts: 487
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2022 3:39 pm
Gender:
Great Britain

Murray wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 8:43 am
Diamond Dave wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 8:22 am Great thread this guys but has made me realise something major that I and perhaps some others may be missing.....
I am trying to achieve a natural immunity with my birds
and try not to treat for anything. (Dont judge me on tha as its not the crux of this post). In particular for young bird sickness. I have not given them anything for maybe 4/5 years. Have to say that it hasnt got any better. I had birds die on me this year as well as previous years.
But here is the realisation...... why would it get better while I am breeding from the same stock birds each year!!!
I am staggered and feel very stupid that I hadnt thought about this before.
The object of natursl immunity is to breed off the ones that survived it and by continuing to breed off the same birds, I have achieved nothing.
So do I have to do away with my treasured stock birds or is treatment the only way around it?
Give that man a cigar! :D
interesting mate, if im honest i have always treated for cocci canker and worms before breeding and before racing and back when i was younger racing i only ever had YBS once and i think they caught it going into a basket with a mates birds as he always got YBS ever dam year and hes still the same to the day which i find strange lol
Buster121
Posts: 8833
Joined: Wed Feb 09, 2022 11:09 am
Gender:
Great Britain

Diamond Dave wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 8:22 am Great thread this guys but has made me realise something major that I and perhaps some others may be missing.....
I am trying to achieve a natural immunity with my birds
and try not to treat for anything. (Dont judge me on tha as its not the crux of this post). In particular for young bird sickness. I have not given them anything for maybe 4/5 years. Have to say that it hasnt got any better. I had birds die on me this year as well as previous years.
But here is the realisation...... why would it get better while I am breeding from the same stock birds each year!!!
I am staggered and feel very stupid that I hadnt thought about this before.
The object of natursl immunity is to breed off the ones that survived it and by continuing to breed off the same birds, I have achieved nothing.
So do I have to do away with my treasured stock birds or is treatment the only way around it?
Yes Dave but do you know it is down to the stockbirds or could it be just one of those things
Sadies Lofts home of decent birds just a useless loft manager, and now a confirmed loser but proud :D :D
User avatar
king
Posts: 1107
Joined: Thu Apr 04, 2024 12:48 am
Location: York
Gender:
Great Britain

Murray wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 3:54 am Well there you go, I'd never thought about it like that. You never stop learning.
A flyer I know is a medicine man. He also is strongly opposed to breeding from old pigeons. I'd never linked the two things. You might be right, king, maybe he's found that his older pigeons lose their fertility.
I'm keen on breeding from young pigeons myself, but not for that reason. I think that if you give your good younger pigeons a try you are giving them the chance to show if they can pass it on. You can get 4 or 5 generations in 10 years instead of 2 or 3, and maybe improve your loft accordingly. And if they are disappointing they aren't there for years in case they throw something.
I like the vitality of young pigeons.
Nature has one rule. The STRONGEST breed, not the youngest. In nature, old age and older individuals are not detrimental to a species. That's why many live very long lives.

It's been proven in pigeons the age of birds has NO bearing on the quality of the young. I too breed off yearlings, but if your looking for NATUAL IMMUNITY the older the bird the stronger that immunity will be.

Many years ago most 10 year old cocks would still be fertile, that has dropped dramatically in recent years, I know many fanciers who's cocks are infertile at 6 or 7 now. That's not a sign of vitality, it's a weak physical constitution.
User avatar
king
Posts: 1107
Joined: Thu Apr 04, 2024 12:48 am
Location: York
Gender:
Great Britain

Diamond Dave wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 8:22 am Great thread this guys but has made me realise something major that I and perhaps some others may be missing.....
I am trying to achieve a natural immunity with my birds
and try not to treat for anything. (Dont judge me on tha as its not the crux of this post). In particular for young bird sickness. I have not given them anything for maybe 4/5 years. Have to say that it hasnt got any better. I had birds die on me this year as well as previous years.
But here is the realisation...... why would it get better while I am breeding from the same stock birds each year!!!
I am staggered and feel very stupid that I hadnt thought about this before.
The object of natursl immunity is to breed off the ones that survived it and by continuing to breed off the same birds, I have achieved nothing.
So do I have to do away with my treasured stock birds or is treatment the only way around it?
BEFORE you blame your stock birds Dave, tell when your young birds get YBS? When racing my own YBs got YBS every year, but ONLY after their first race. My stock didn't give it to them they brought it home from the race.

If I ever raced again, I wouldn't race ybs. Just private train, or try to give them a race with old birds.
Andy
Posts: 365
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2026 7:35 pm
Gender:
Great Britain

As I’ve said before I don’t treat for anything. Yes I have the odd birds get sick or go off colour. But I don’t remove them from the loft or treat them, they either recover or don’t. They are left in the loft with all my other birds. I might then get a few more that go downhill a bit but also others that never show any signs of anything but good health, more often than not my best ones. Although the ones that have gone sick and recovered you could argue that they shouldn’t have gone sick but you never know what they have been exposed to to have made them sick. I would have no qualms in breeding from these birds that have recovered, provided they have made a full recovery, as they have shown strength to have come through an illness, but also because their immune system should now be even stronger.
I have had the odd ones just recently get poorly since separating them. Very wet droppings and although still eating losing weight fast and sitting hunched up. I did lose 3 hens and have a 10 year old cock not looking very good but the others that were down for a few days have now or are recovering and putting the weight back on. The strange thing is that it was mainly the older birds. The ones I lost were all hens. A 12 year old a 10 year old and a 3 year old. But I have young birds and latebreds in the same section that have shown nothing with good droppings.
Wiley
Posts: 65
Joined: Sun Oct 11, 2026 10:39 pm
Great Britain

king wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 2:12 am
Wiley wrote: Sun Nov 08, 2026 3:46 pm I've been to many top class fanciers all treat pigeons.

There was an era in the racing pigeon and British homing world where people used to say they never treated, as a scribe, and visited some of those lofts and seeing the different coloured water and the potions in their cupboards I know it isn't true.
The majority of fanciers WILL treat for everything, simply because they see others treating, including top fanciers. And many of those top fanciers HAVE to treat because it's the only way they can get their birds to perform. having bought their birds from fanciers who also treat.

The thing that doesn't add up is? If the majority of fanciers who treat for EVERYTHING, them why is there so much infectious diseases and viruses within the sport? I started racing in 1975 and fanciers treated for basic, worms, canker, coxi, one eyed cold ect. ALL were easy to treat. Nobody used a vet, anything that got ill was removed. Pigeons dying in the loft never happen. Today it's common for fanciers to find dead birds in their lofts, especially young birds.

Here's a tip when you visit a loft. Ask him how old his oldest bird is that is still filling it's eggs? If it's less than 7 years old, he probably treats for everything, and if you buy from him you'll have to do the same.

Now I'm not against treating WERE it's needed. But don't think you can beat nature, you CAN'T treat for something they do not have to stop it in the future. I have medications in my cupboard just in case, when I need them I've got them, you can't afford to wait week for them arriving. But they nearly always end up out of date, unopened and in the bin.
King I treat for everything and my two oldest stock cocks are 17 this coming year? And they have been treated for everything since 2010 when they was babies?
Andy
Posts: 365
Joined: Sun Jun 14, 2026 7:35 pm
Gender:
Great Britain

king wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 1:37 pm
Murray wrote: Mon Nov 09, 2026 3:54 am Well there you go, I'd never thought about it like that. You never stop learning.
A flyer I know is a medicine man. He also is strongly opposed to breeding from old pigeons. I'd never linked the two things. You might be right, king, maybe he's found that his older pigeons lose their fertility.
I'm keen on breeding from young pigeons myself, but not for that reason. I think that if you give your good younger pigeons a try you are giving them the chance to show if they can pass it on. You can get 4 or 5 generations in 10 years instead of 2 or 3, and maybe improve your loft accordingly. And if they are disappointing they aren't there for years in case they throw something.
I like the vitality of young pigeons.
Nature has one rule. The STRONGEST breed, not the youngest. In nature, old age and older individuals are not detrimental to a species. That's why many live very long lives.

It's been proven in pigeons the age of birds has NO bearing on the quality of the young. I too breed off yearlings, but if your looking for NATUAL IMMUNITY the older the bird the stronger that immunity will be.

Many years ago most 10 year old cocks would still be fertile, that has dropped dramatically in recent years, I know many fanciers who's cocks are infertile at 6 or 7 now. That's not a sign of vitality, it's a weak physical constitution.
I have a 12 year old and a 10 year old hen here still laying regularly. I had an old cock that was still filling his eggs at 17.
Murray
Posts: 578
Joined: Mon Jun 15, 2026 10:48 pm
Australia

I do not wish to appear critical of old stock pigeons. Far from it. There are pigeons that produce top performers at a great age.
What I am suggesting, and I have found to be the case, is that you can take young pigeons, even late breds, and breed from them. You can test the offspring and immediately put them back into stock. In less than two years you have the next generation and may have totally changed the loft.
I am only saying you can, not that you should.
Murray's Loft
"Well THAT didn't work". :D
Post Reply